Updated November 2026
In short: straight-edged steak knives cut cleanly and can be honed and resharpened at home, so they stay sharp for years. Serrated knives feel sharp for longer out of the box, but they saw through meat rather than slice it and are hard to resharpen. For most homes, a set of 6 is enough. For a big family or holiday table, choose 8 or 12.
Straight vs serrated steak knives
| Straight (plain) edge | Serrated edge | |
|---|---|---|
| How it cuts | Slices cleanly through the fibres | Saws through with its teeth |
| The cut surface | Smooth, so juices stay in the slice | Rougher |
| Sharpening | Easy to hone and resharpen at home | Needs special tools or a professional |
| Lifespan | Many years with simple care | Teeth wear down and are hard to restore |
| Best for | People who want a lasting set | Low-maintenance, budget sets |
A straight edge does need a light hone now and then. That two-minute habit is what keeps a good set cutting like new for years. All four of our sets have straight edges.
Blade length and handle
A steak knife doesn't need a long blade. Around 4 to 5 inches is enough to cross a ribeye or a strip in a single stroke while staying easy to control at the table. Three of our sets have a 4.5-inch blade and a 5-inch handle (9.5 inches overall); the Herringbone set has a 5-inch blade (10 inches overall).
Look for a handle you'd enjoy holding through a whole meal: a full grip, some weight, and pins that hold the handle firmly to the tang. Natural materials like rosewood or stag also make the table look finished.
Damascus or black hammered stainless?
- Damascus (hammered, or plain on the Herringbone set) is hand-forged from layered steel, so every blade shows its own wavy pattern. No two knives are alike, which makes it a true heirloom set. Hand wash and dry right away to keep the pattern bright.
- Black hammered stainless has a dramatic, low-shine black finish over a hammered texture, with a bright ground edge. It's the more modern look on the table. Use a soft sponge and no abrasive scrubbers, so the black finish lasts.
Both cut the same way. The choice comes down to the look you want on your table.
How many steak knives do you need?
| Set size | Good for |
|---|---|
| 6 | Most families, and couples who entertain |
| 8 | Regular dinner parties |
| 12 | Large families and holiday tables |
| 16 | Big gatherings, or a set to share across generations |
A simple rule: count your dinner plates and match the set to them. When a set is a gift, it's usually better to give one size larger than the household seems to need.
Caring for steak knives (no dishwasher)
- Hand wash in warm, soapy water and dry right away. Dishwashers knock edges against each other and dry out wood and natural handles.
- Store the set in its leather roll. It keeps the edges apart and protected between dinners.
- Hone lightly before a big meal. A few strokes on a honing rod realign the edge.
- Cut on wood or plates, not glass or stone boards.
See our knife care guide and the Damascus care guide.
Gift guide: our four steak knife sets
Every set comes in a full-grain leather roll, in sets of 6, 8, 12 or 16, with free engraving.
- Black Hammered Steak Knife Set — Rosewood Handles. Black hammered blades and warm rosewood: a modern classic for the everyday table.
- Hammered Damascus Steak Knife Set — Rosewood Handles. Hand-forged Damascus with a pattern unique to every blade: the heirloom pick.
- Black Hammered Steak Knife Set — Stag Handles. Natural stag handles with black blades: the statement set for a holiday table.
- Herringbone Damascus Steak Knife Set — Rosewood & Olive Wood Handles. Hand-forged Damascus blades with herringbone handles of rosewood and olive wood: the showpiece for a wedding or housewarming.
Compare them all on our Steak Knife Sets page.
Engraving ideas
Engraving turns a set into a keepsake. Ideas that fit within 20 characters:
- Weddings: the couple's surname and year ("The Martins · 2026")
- Housewarmings: the house name or address number
- Holidays: a family name for the set that comes out every Thanksgiving
- Retirements and anniversaries: initials and a date
Engraving is free, adds 2 business days, and engraved sets are final sale. Details on our custom engraving page.
Carving the roast first?
If a brisket or turkey comes to the table before the steaks, read brisket knife vs carving knife and see our Brisket Slicers.
FAQ
Are straight-edge steak knives better than serrated?
For a set you want to keep, yes. A straight edge slices cleanly and can be resharpened at home. Serrated edges saw through the meat and are hard to resharpen once the teeth wear.
How many steak knives should be in a set?
Six suits most families, 8 a dinner party, and 12 or 16 a large holiday table.
Can steak knives go in the dishwasher?
Please don't. Hand wash and dry right away, then store the set in its leather roll. The edges and the natural handles last much longer that way.
Are Damascus steak knives worth it?
If you want an heirloom set, yes. Hand-forged Damascus cuts as well as quality stainless, and every blade has its own pattern, so the set becomes something to hand down. If you prefer easy care and a modern look, choose the black hammered sets.
What blade length is best for a steak knife?
About 4 to 5 inches. That crosses a ribeye or strip in one stroke and stays easy to control at the table.
Do steak knives need sharpening?
Straight-edged ones do, now and then. Hone lightly before a big meal and sharpen once or twice a year, depending on use. See how to sharpen a Damascus knife.
Can I engrave a steak knife set?
Yes, free: up to 20 characters on the blades or the leather roll. Engraving adds 2 business days, and engraved sets are final sale.
Shop Steak Knife Sets →
Shop Brisket Slicers →
Gifts for the BBQ Lover →